Welcome back, RazorMP here! Today, we're diving deep into a head-to-head comparison of four popular compact pistols: the Canik Prime, Smith & Wesson Carry Comp, Springfield Armory Hellcat Pro Comp OSP, and the Sig Sauer P365 XMACRO. Each pistol offers a robust 17-round capacity and brings distinct strengths—and a few points to consider. If you're seeking a versatile, performance-driven compact pistol, keep reading!
First, a huge thank you to my membership subscribers—your ongoing support makes these detailed reviews possible. Special thanks as well to Scottsdale Tactical for their continued support of this channel. You can find a full parts list and additional details at my website, www.razormp.com.
Canik Prime
The Canik Prime is loaded with features that maximize performance and comfort. Highlights include:
- Flat-faced aluminum diamond-cut trigger with a crisp ninety-degree break for superior trigger control.
- Enhanced full-grip stippling for a secure hold in any condition.
- Integrally compensated slide and ported barrel that significantly reduce recoil and muzzle rise, improving accuracy and shot recovery speed.
Smith & Wesson Carry Comp
This pistol distinguishes itself through:
- Strategically positioned compensation ports for remarkable recoil and muzzle-rise reduction.
- A slightly longer 4.22-inch barrel with Armornite® finish and an optics-ready slide.
- Performance Center flat-face trigger, along with my addition of a magazine extender to enhance grip length and achieve the 17-round capacity.
Springfield Armory Hellcat Pro Comp OSP
The most compact and lightweight pistol in our lineup, notable for:
- Integral single-port compensator in its 3.7-inch barrel for effective recoil reduction.
- Exceptional concealability and practicality for everyday carry, despite being optics-ready and slim.
- Ability to achieve a 17-round capacity with compatible magazines.
Sig Sauer P365 XMACRO
Impressively packing 17+1 rounds, the XMACRO offers:
- Integrated compensator for exceptional recoil management.
- Customization options—I outfitted mine with a Sharp Bros aluminum lower grip, wood inserts, and a built-in gas pedal for improved control.
- Optics-ready slide and interchangeable backstraps to suit various hand sizes.
Range Performance Comparison
To fully evaluate these pistols, I conducted extensive range tests focusing on:
- Accuracy and grouping consistency
- Three-shot drill performance
- Recoil control and rapid-fire stability
The performance across all pistols was remarkably close, with minimal differences in accuracy and split times. Initially, I had my predictions, but after thorough testing, XXXXXX ultimately edged out the competition for me, excelling in both grouping precision and shot recovery speed.
Final Thoughts
Each pistol showcased impressive performance, with minor variances tailored to individual preferences:
- **Canik Prime:** Exceptional trigger, reliability, and overall value.
- **Smith & Wesson Carry Comp:** Superior recoil management and comfort enhancements.
- **Springfield Hellcat Pro Comp OSP:** Ideal for daily concealed carry, emphasizing compact size.
- **Sig Sauer P365 XMACRO:** Maximum capacity and customized ergonomic comfort.
Which pistol aligns best with your needs? I'd love to hear your thoughts—let me know your choice!
Thanks once again to all my supporters and Scottsdale Tactical. Stay connected and follow me on Instagram (@razor.mp) and X (@RazorMP_Actual) for updates and more insights. Visit www.razormp.com for the complete parts list and further details.
As always, I'll see you on the high ground or in the next review—RazorMP out!
Canik Mete Prime (after April 15th): Scottsdale Tactical
Smith & Wesson M&P Carry Comp: Scottsdale Tactical
Sig Sauer P365 X-Macro: Scottsdale Tactical
Springfield Armory Hellcat: Scottsdale Tactical